NewsMarkets

Sports

Michigan Benches Bryce Underwood for Tommy Carr Ahead of Indiana Game

Coach Kyle Whittingham has benched quarterback Bryce Underwood in favor of Tommy Carr following their win over Penn State, with the starter for the upcoming game against Indiana yet to be announced.

4 publishers · 14 articles · first seen 17 Oct 2026 · updated 17d ago

Headline and summary written by an AI model from the linked articles; not reviewed by a person. How this was made

First reported by SI Feed, 12 min ahead of the next publisher · who breaks stories first

This story has stopped developing; this page is its permanent record. More from that day

The odds

How the odds moved · Michigan
0%50%100%1%19 Oct, 05:03 UTCnowwww.espn.com: Michigan mum on Carr, Underwood as starting QB vs. No. 6 Indiana · 19 Oct, 14:50 UTCSI Feed: Bryce Underwood Transfer Portal: Top 5 Best Teams If Star QB Cuts Ties With Michigan · 21 Oct, 11:33 UTCSI Feed: Tommy Carr Expected to Make First Career Start vs. Indiana · 21 Oct, 01:37 UTCfeeds.bleacherreport.com: Michigan's Bryce Underwood Benched, Latest Rumors on Wolverines' QB Plans vs. Indiana · 21 Oct, 00:11 UTCCBS Sports Headlines: Michigan starting QB Tommy Carr vs. Indiana: What's next for Bryce Underwood? · 21 Oct, 00:09 UTCSI Feed: Joel Klatt's Take Shows Why Michigan Can't Go Back to the Bryce Underwood Well · 20 Oct, 16:34 UTCSI Feed: Jason Beck Praises Bryce Underwood's Improvement, But Tommy Carr Sparked Michigan's Offense · 20 Oct, 13:57 UTCfeeds.bleacherreport.com: Michigan HC Coy on Bryce Underwood-Tommy Carr QB1 Decision Ahead of Game vs. Cignetti, No. 6 Indiana · 19 Oct, 16:18 UTC

Each tick is a source publishing on this story · 6 more published before price tracking began

Price data
TimeChance of yes
now1%
24 Oct, 19:37 UTC18%
24 Oct, 19:23 UTC44%
24 Oct, 18:50 UTC27%
24 Oct, 18:29 UTC26%
24 Oct, 17:54 UTC22%
24 Oct, 17:29 UTC22%
24 Oct, 16:54 UTC26%
24 Oct, 16:22 UTC25%
24 Oct, 15:55 UTC28%
24 Oct, 07:17 UTC29%
24 Oct, 06:58 UTC28%
24 Oct, 01:13 UTC28%
23 Oct, 23:36 UTC29%
23 Oct, 23:17 UTC28%
23 Oct, 19:19 UTC28%
23 Oct, 16:29 UTC28%
23 Oct, 15:20 UTC28%
23 Oct, 14:51 UTC29%
23 Oct, 14:24 UTC28%
23 Oct, 09:21 UTC28%
23 Oct, 01:18 UTC29%
23 Oct, 00:55 UTC28%
22 Oct, 12:14 UTC29%
22 Oct, 00:52 UTC28%
21 Oct, 22:53 UTC29%
21 Oct, 22:17 UTC28%
21 Oct, 16:01 UTC29%
21 Oct, 15:53 UTC28%
20 Oct, 20:02 UTC29%
20 Oct, 19:48 UTC28%
20 Oct, 19:21 UTC27%
20 Oct, 14:33 UTC29%
20 Oct, 12:25 UTC30%
20 Oct, 11:55 UTC29%
20 Oct, 11:26 UTC30%
20 Oct, 07:49 UTC29%
20 Oct, 06:13 UTC30%
19 Oct, 05:03 UTC29%

The story so far

4 publishers have covered this in 14 articles since 17 Oct 2026. SI Feed published first, on 17 October at 21:32 UTC; feeds.bleacherreport.com followed 12 min later. The most recent article, from SI Feed, appeared on 21 October at 11:33 UTC.

Outlets reporting it: www.espn.com (major outlet), SI Feed, feeds.bleacherreport.com, CBS Sports Headlines.

One prediction market prices this story:

  • Michigan — resolved “No” on 24 Oct 2026. The market resolves to Yes if Michigan wins the college football game against Indiana scheduled for October 24, 2026. It resolves to No if Michigan does not win that specific game. Readers often mistake the resolution source, but only the official result of this particular match counts, not other games or general team performance.

Odds are the market's probability that the outcome happens, updated every few minutes. They are information about what traders expect, not a forecast we make and not investment advice.

How it unfolded

Every source in the order it published, with the odds on Michigan at that moment. A dash means the source published before we started tracking prices.

  1. SI FeedBryce Underwood Benched vs. Penn State, Tommy Carr Takes Over—
  2. feeds.bleacherreport.comBryce Underwood Benched by Michigan, Replaced by Lloyd Carr's Grandson Tommy vs. Penn State—
  3. CBS Sports HeadlinesMichigan benches QB Bryce Underwood vs. Penn State: Tommy Carr replaces former five-star recruit—
  4. SI FeedMichigan’s Hope for a Hometown Hero in Bryce Underwood Is Finished—
  5. SI FeedTommy Carr or Bryce Underwood? Michigan HC Kyle Whittingham Playing Things Close to Vest—
  6. SI FeedMichigan QB Tommy Carr Speaks On Bryce Underwood After Taking His Spot—
  7. www.espn.comMichigan mum on Carr, Underwood as starting QB vs. No. 6 Indiana29%
  8. feeds.bleacherreport.comMichigan HC Coy on Bryce Underwood-Tommy Carr QB1 Decision Ahead of Game vs. Cignetti, No. 6 Indiana29%
  9. SI FeedJason Beck Praises Bryce Underwood's Improvement, But Tommy Carr Sparked Michigan's Offense30%▲1 points since the previous source
  10. SI FeedJoel Klatt's Take Shows Why Michigan Can't Go Back to the Bryce Underwood Well29%▼1 points since the previous source
  11. Show 4 later sources
    1. CBS Sports HeadlinesMichigan starting QB Tommy Carr vs. Indiana: What's next for Bryce Underwood?29%
    2. feeds.bleacherreport.comMichigan's Bryce Underwood Benched, Latest Rumors on Wolverines' QB Plans vs. Indiana29%
    3. SI FeedTommy Carr Expected to Make First Career Start vs. Indiana29%
    4. SI FeedBryce Underwood Transfer Portal: Top 5 Best Teams If Star QB Cuts Ties With Michigan29%
  12. Market resolved: No

Sources

Every article we clustered into this story. Headlines link to the publisher.

  1. Michigan mum on Carr, Underwood as starting QB vs. No. 6 Indiana www.espn.com ·
  2. Bryce Underwood Transfer Portal: Top 5 Best Teams If Star QB Cuts Ties With Michigan SI Feed
  3. Tommy Carr Expected to Make First Career Start vs. Indiana SI Feed
  4. Michigan's Bryce Underwood Benched, Latest Rumors on Wolverines' QB Plans vs. Indiana feeds.bleacherreport.com
  5. Michigan starting QB Tommy Carr vs. Indiana: What's next for Bryce Underwood? CBS Sports Headlines
  6. Joel Klatt's Take Shows Why Michigan Can't Go Back to the Bryce Underwood Well SI Feed
Show 8 more sources
  1. Jason Beck Praises Bryce Underwood's Improvement, But Tommy Carr Sparked Michigan's Offense SI Feed
  2. Michigan HC Coy on Bryce Underwood-Tommy Carr QB1 Decision Ahead of Game vs. Cignetti, No. 6 Indiana feeds.bleacherreport.com
  3. Michigan QB Tommy Carr Speaks On Bryce Underwood After Taking His Spot SI Feed
  4. Tommy Carr or Bryce Underwood? Michigan HC Kyle Whittingham Playing Things Close to Vest SI Feed
  5. Michigan’s Hope for a Hometown Hero in Bryce Underwood Is Finished SI Feed
  6. Michigan benches QB Bryce Underwood vs. Penn State: Tommy Carr replaces former five-star recruit CBS Sports Headlines
  7. Bryce Underwood Benched by Michigan, Replaced by Lloyd Carr's Grandson Tommy vs. Penn State feeds.bleacherreport.com
  8. Bryce Underwood Benched vs. Penn State, Tommy Carr Takes Over SI Feed

Related prediction markets

Linked by software because they are about the same subject. Most ask a different question from the one this story reports, so read each market's own question. How often the link is right

  • Resolved Michigan No 14d ago

    The market favoured No at 71% a day out, and it won. How often it's right

    Wrong market?

In this story

Embed this story

Paste this into any web page to show the live odds, with a link back here.