Giants to Start J.J. McCarthy Against Texans

How it unfolded

Every source in the order it published, with the odds on J.J. McCarthy records 3+ passing touchdowns in a single game at that moment. A dash means the source published before we started tracking prices.

1. 27 Sept, 22:46www.espn.comHarbaugh: Winston is QB1 even if Giants add another QB27%
2. 28 Sept, 02:13SI FeedJameis Winston Does "What Was Required" in Giants Win, but Questions About QB Future Linger27%
3. 29 Sept, 11:41CBS Sports HeadlinesWhen will J.J. McCarthy start for Giants? Why John Harbaugh could make QB change sooner than expected17%▼10 points since the previous source
4. 30 Sept, 09:00The Guardian SportJameis Winston is now the New York Giants’ starter. He’s far from a goofball hero though27%▲10 points since the previous source
5. 1 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants Jameis Winston Opens Up on Job Security After J.J. McCarthy Trade27%
6. 1 Oct, 14:00SI FeedGiants' Shelby Harris Says J.J. McCarthy Landed in the Right Place at the Right Time27%
7. 2 Oct, 16:00SI FeedGiants OC Matt Nagy Reveals What's Impressed Him Most So Far About J.J. McCarthy54%▲27 points since the previous source
8. 2 Oct, 19:24SI FeedJ.J. McCarthy's Crash Course: Inside the Giants' Plan to Get Their New QB Up to Speed54%
9. 3 Oct, 11:33www.espn.comJameis Winston has time to prove he's the Giants' starter16%▼38 points since the previous source
10. 3 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants Mailbag: Andrew Thomas' Health, J.J. McCarthy's Timeline and the Pass Rush Problem16%
11. Show 80 later sources

    1. 3 Oct, 23:57SI FeedGiants Elevate QB Jake Haener, OLB Trace Ford From Practice Squad for Cardinals Game16%
    2. 4 Oct, 16:30SI FeedGiants vs. Cardinals Live Blog: Updates, Analysis and Highlights From Week 4 at MetLife3%▼13 points since the previous source
    3. 5 Oct, 12:00SI FeedJameis Winston, Giants "Found a Way" Against Cardinals as QB Chatter Swirls3%
    4. 5 Oct, 20:05feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy's Giants Role for Commanders Game Discussed by John Harbaugh After Vikings Trade3%
    5. 6 Oct, 17:05SI FeedHarbaugh's "1-0" Mindset Is Just What the Giants Need Right Now31%▲28 points since the previous source
    6. 7 Oct, 15:00SI FeedFrom J.J. McCarthy to the Center Spot: Giants Storylines Heading Into Week 523%▼8 points since the previous source
    7. 9 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants’ QB Jameis Winston Reveals His One Goal17%▼6 points since the previous source
    8. 10 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants Mailbag: Your Questions on McCarthy, Winston, Harbaugh and More17%
    9. 10 Oct, 22:00SI FeedBiggest Area Where the Giants Need to Improve in Chase for NFC East Title17%
    10. 11 Oct, 15:37SI FeedGiants, Commanders Inactives: McLaurin Active; McCarthy Moves Up to QB210%▼7 points since the previous source
    11. 12 Oct, 16:00SI FeedJameis Winston Answers Critics With Historic Day in Giants Tie20%▲10 points since the previous source
    12. 12 Oct, 23:13feeds.bleacherreport.comGiants' Jameis Winston Likened to Michael Jordan, Abraham Lincoln by John Harbaugh in New Video20%
    13. 13 Oct, 17:00SI FeedNFL Insider Explains Why Giants Really Traded for J.J. McCarthy20%
    14. 14 Oct, 01:29feeds.bleacherreport.comTerrell Owens Reveals He Calls Jameis Winston Weekly Amid Giants QB1 Role & Talks Cowboys Struggles20%
    15. 14 Oct, 12:00SI FeedBorn of Necessity, Giants’ Pass-Heavy Approach Could Stick20%
    16. 15 Oct, 14:03SI FeedWhy "The Jameis Winston Experience" Has Been Working for the Giants20%
    17. 15 Oct, 14:38feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy's Usage Explained by Giants' John Harbaugh, Teases Expanded Role for QB20%
    18. 16 Oct, 16:47SI FeedSaints vs. Giants: Jameis Winston's Return Headlines 3 Key Storylines20%
    19. 17 Oct, 00:02SI FeedIsaiah Likely Feels at Home in Giants’ Offense, and His Chemistry With Jameis Winston Is Growing20%
    20. 17 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants Mailbag: Run Game Woes, Skattebo’s Fumbles, Deonte Banks’ Contract and More20%
    21. 17 Oct, 18:00SI FeedGiants’ O-Line Is Trending Up, but the Run Game and Tackle Injuries Are Red Flags20%
    22. 18 Oct, 19:50feeds.bleacherreport.comJameis Winston Benched by Giants, J.J. McCarthy Throws INT After Replacing QB vs. Saints20%
    23. 18 Oct, 19:50feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy Box Score Stats, Highlights After Jameis Winston Benched in Giants vs. Saints20%
    24. 18 Oct, 19:57CBS Sports HeadlinesJameis Winston benched: Giants make move to J.J. McCarthy during Saints blowout20%
    25. 18 Oct, 20:55feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy Praised by Giants' Harbaugh After Replacing Jameis Winston, Week 7 Starter TBD20%
    26. 18 Oct, 21:00SI FeedGiants Comeback Bid Falls Short in 34-27 Loss to Saints20%
    27. 18 Oct, 23:12SI FeedGiants Fall Short vs. Saints, and the McCarthy-Winston Debate Is On20%
    28. 18 Oct, 23:35www.espn.comGiants' QB and RB situations left unsettled after home loss to Saints20%
    29. 19 Oct, 00:17SI FeedWhy Keeping J.J. McCarthy on the Bench Is the Smart Long-Term Move for the Giants20%
    30. 19 Oct, 02:12SI FeedMcCarthy Makes History in Relief, but Giants Fall Short vs. Saints20%
    31. 19 Oct, 11:31CBS Sports HeadlinesGiants have a QB controversy: J.J. McCarthy makes case to replace Jameis Winston20%
    32. 19 Oct, 14:00SI FeedGiants QB Debate Heats Up After McCarthy’s Record-Setting Comeback Bid20%
    33. 19 Oct, 20:06feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy, Jameis Winston Giants QB1 Competition Discussed by John Harbaugh Ahead of Texans Game20%
    34. 19 Oct, 20:08CBS Sports HeadlinesJohn Harbaugh provides update on Giants' QB situation between JJ McCarthy, Jameis Winston20%
    35. 19 Oct, 20:26SI FeedJJ McCarthy Shines in Relief, Could Start in Week 7: Fantasy Football Impact20%
    36. 19 Oct, 20:45SI FeedJ.J. McCarthy Fantasy Football Outlook: Would a Week 7 Start Make Him Worth Adding?20%
    37. 19 Oct, 21:01www.espn.comHarbaugh: Giants 'honing in on' QB decision for Sunday vs. Texans20%
    38. 19 Oct, 21:33SI FeedHarbaugh Leaves Door Open to Quarterback Change as Giants Weigh Winston, McCarthy20%
    39. 20 Oct, 11:31SI FeedJ.J. McCarthy Shares Romantic Sideline Moment With Wife Before Making Giants Debut20%
    40. 20 Oct, 12:05www.espn.comJameis Winston vs. J.J. McCarthy: Pros and cons of Giants QBs20%
    41. 20 Oct, 18:32SI FeedGiants at a Crossroads: Is It Time to Turn the Offense Over to J.J. McCarthy?20%
    42. 21 Oct, 14:30SI FeedGiants Hold at No. 20 in Power Rankings as McCarthy-or-Winston Debate Looms20%
    43. 21 Oct, 16:13feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy Reportedly Named Giants QB1 Over Jameis Winston for Giants' NFL Week 7 Game vs. Texans20%
    44. 21 Oct, 16:13feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy Named Giants QB1 Over Jameis Winston for Giants' NFL Week 7 Game vs. Texans20%
    45. 21 Oct, 16:14www.espn.comSource: Giants to start McCarthy at QB this week against Texans20%
    46. 21 Oct, 16:22CBS Sports HeadlinesGiants plan to start QB J.J. McCarthy over Jameis Winston vs. Texans, per report20%
    47. 21 Oct, 16:31SI FeedReport: Giants Will Start J.J. McCarthy Over Jameis Winston Against Texans20%
    48. 21 Oct, 16:38CBS Sports HeadlinesGiants plan to start JJ McCarthy vs. Texans in Week 7, per report20%
    49. 21 Oct, 20:13SI FeedWhy Starting J.J. McCarthy is the Right Move for the Giants, and Why It Isn’t20%
    50. 21 Oct, 20:26feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy Reacts to Being Named Giants QB1 Over Winston After Leading Comeback Bid vs. Saints20%
    51. 21 Oct, 21:22SI FeedTexans' DeMeco Ryans Shrugs Off Giants' Decision to Start J.J. McCarthy20%
    52. 21 Oct, 22:32SI FeedHarbaugh Explains Switch to J.J. McCarthy at QB: “This Is Going to Be Our Direction”20%
    53. 21 Oct, 22:40feeds.bleacherreport.comJameis Winston Reacts to Benching in New Video After J.J. McCarthy Named Giants QB120%
    54. 21 Oct, 23:50SI FeedGiants Have Bigger Problems Than the QB Decision20%
    55. 22 Oct, 10:00CBS Sports HeadlinesNFL Week 7 upset alert: Can Giants upset Texans with JJ McCarthy at QB? Can Falcons beat 49ers?20%
    56. 22 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants QB Switch Q&A: Why McCarthy, Why Now?20%
    57. 22 Oct, 12:39CBS Sports HeadlinesPrisco's NFL Week 7 picks ahead of Patriots vs. Bears; Dream take WNBA Finals lead on Valkyries20%
    58. 22 Oct, 14:00SI FeedJ.J. McCarthy Says Past Struggles in Minnesota Have Prepared Him to Start for the Giants20%
    59. 22 Oct, 16:00SI FeedJameis Winston Takes Demotion in Stride as J.J. McCarthy Steps In for Giants20%
    60. 22 Oct, 18:47SI FeedJ.J. McCarthy Is Projected to Get Walloped By the Texans20%
    61. 23 Oct, 12:00SI FeedWhy Isaiah Likely Is Sold on New Starting Giants QB J.J. McCarthy20%
    62. 23 Oct, 14:16SI FeedGiants Reopen More of the Playbook for J.J. McCarthy’s First Start vs. Texans20%
    63. 23 Oct, 16:00SI FeedGiants Bet on McCarthy’s Arm as Nabers Vows to Get Open20%
    64. 24 Oct, 16:00SI FeedGiants Face Toughest Defense Since Week 2 as McCarthy Makes First Start20%
    65. 24 Oct, 16:34feeds.bleacherreport.comJ.J. McCarthy 'Impressed from the Moment He' Joined Giants After Vikings Trade, NFL Rumors Reveal20%
    66. 24 Oct, 22:18CBS Sports HeadlinesGiants' John Harbaugh details J.J. McCarthy decision with convincing explanation: 'Heck of a skill set'20%
    67. 25 Oct, 11:28feeds.bleacherreport.comCam Skattebo's Workload, J.J. McCarthy's Future as QB1 Updated in New Giants Rumors20%
    68. 25 Oct, 14:00SI FeedWhy the Giants Will Beat the Texans, Why They Won’t, and a Prediction20%
    69. 25 Oct, 20:42SI FeedGiants Ride Cam Skattebo’s 124 Rushing Yards to a 27-21 OT Win Over Texans20%
    70. 25 Oct, 21:49SI FeedIt’s Only Been Five Quarters, But J.J. McCarthy Is Giving John Harbaugh Plenty to Think About20%
    71. 25 Oct, 21:54feeds.bleacherreport.comEverything J.J. McCarthy Said About Winning 1st Start as Giants QB Since Vikings Trade20%
    72. 25 Oct, 22:07CBS Sports HeadlinesJ.J. McCarthy, Cam Skattebo seize second chances as John Harbaugh's surprising Giants keep rolling20%
    73. 26 Oct, 00:30www.espn.comLet's overreact to NFL Week 7: J.J. McCarthy-led Giants to make playoffs?20%
    74. 26 Oct, 03:05SI FeedJ.J. McCarthy Delivers a Winning Debut as Giants Starter, Beating Texans in Overtime20%
    75. 26 Oct, 17:52SI FeedThe Giants’ Run Game Was DOA. Then Week 7 Happened20%
    76. 26 Oct, 20:31SI FeedJohn Harbaugh Offers Update on Giants’ Kicker Plans20%
    77. 27 Oct, 19:24feeds.bleacherreport.comGiants' J.J. McCarthy Explains 'Corny' Reason for Not Wearing Eye Black vs. C.J. Stroud, Texans20%
    78. 28 Oct, 00:23feeds.bleacherreport.comJaxson Dart, J.J. McCarthy's Giants Future Addressed by GM Joe Schoen After Injury, Trade20%
    79. 29 Oct, 12:00SI FeedGiants Rise in Latest MMQB Power Rankings Poll20%
    80. 29 Oct, 14:10SI FeedNew York Giants at the Bye: 5 Factors That Fueled a 4-2-1 Start20%
12. NowCurrent odds20%